« 3/4 Marines return to Iraq | Main | Big Balls »
December 29, 2004
3/1 Update from Fallujah
This is a few weeks old but I just received it - here's the latest from LtCol Buhl in Fallujah:
Greetings from the City of Fallujah. |
Here is the story, written by Staff Sgt. Nathaniel T. Garcia, referenced in LtCol Buhl's letter:
"The feeling of hot metal going into your body has become pretty familiar, and I don't like that," said Cpl. Robert Joseph Mitchell. |
Posted by Deb at December 29, 2004 02:58 AM
Trackback Pings
TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.marinecorpsmoms.com/mt-tb.cgi/465
Comments
Comment deleted by Deb with the reminder that this site is not a platform to spew hate towards our troops.
Posted by: anon at January 3, 2005 07:04 PM
Deb, as a courtesy to you and the Marines this will be my last post here. But I want you to know that you have inspired me. I am not surprised that you contend that my words are meant to, "spew hatred towards our troops."
I spend a lot of time researching this war, so much time in fact, that I no longer use American media as a source of information. I suggest you do the same. In particular, look to the BBC, they are the most unbiased, but also look to AP and Reuters. Of course, I do not trust Al Jazeera, I call it the 'Fox of the Middle East', but there is some value in the footage shown.
I am sorry. I apologize to you and the United States Marine Corps. For a long time I too wanted to be in the military, but now I can see that if I am going to help cure this situation I will need to approach this from a different angle.
Today, the Spring semester starts. I should have gotten more sleep, but I am too excited about my new courses. And, yes, I have spent time thinking about the Marines and Iraq.
Because you have inspired me, and because I really do love the troops, I am going to demonstrate my affection today by starting an organization at school dedicated to educating college students about this war. I do not know the law regarding minors, so I have to study that with great care before I begin to inform highschool juniors and seniors. But you can bet that I am going to make my professional contacts today.
I do love this country, Deb, and that is why I am going to act according to my conscience. Maybe I am too old or too educated or too experienced to make a viable US Marine, but that does not mean I am not going to contribute to the cause somehow.
I am not against war by any means. But I am against the harassment, the neglect, and above all, the killing of innocent civilians. I have read too many credible accounts of atrocities, seen too many pictures of dying children, too many sounds of sobbing mothers. A true warrior lives by an unbreakable code of honor. He is not afraid to stand up for justice, and will even risk his own death to preserve what is right, true, and, yes, human.
I wrote to a Senator explaining the need for a new kind of soldier. It is my opinion that the number one crucial component lacking in the soul of the present day service man is conscience. I would like to choose conscripts from the prison system. I will preclude highschool graduates and fathers from service, as their priorities are elswhere, as has been seen, by the interest in comming home. That is the goal: to come home. But that is not going to win this war. Therefore, if the United States is able to create a special team of young, marginal felons to be trained as light infantry, I think we could then wrap this thing up in Iraq.
Further, I would like to educate my soldiers in moral philosophy: Kant, Hume, Hobbes, etc. I know that sounds strange, but a warrior is not a golem, he is a well centered and focused human being that understands the gravity and tragedy of war. I think with this kind of soldier we will no longer hear about Marine snipers killing eight-year-olds or about the abuses of innocents, especially children, forced to experience the hell of a mock execution, the denial of aid, the denial of food, water...
So, farewell to you all. I pray with the deepest earnest that all of your sons come home safe. Tell them to go to school when they get home.
Over and Out,
MATTSON
Posted by: Mattson at January 4, 2005 04:18 AM
Sorry, I should have explained better - I'll go in and amend the edit to make it clear that I was not referring to your post. Your comments are fine - I don't agree with them, but I don't have a problem with what you're saying. My edit was in response to a number of comments that I removed from an anonymous poster. They were filled with hate towards our troops, going so far as to call our Marines "baby-killers". I'm a proponent of free speech and open expression of opinion but this extreme viewpoint would be very hurtful to parents of Marines who read this website and I have a responsibility to them too.
You speak of Marine snipers taking out eight-year olds. Do you think this is routine? I have heard so many stories of returning Marines who took extraordinary lengths to protect the innocent civilians who were terrorized under Saddam's regime. Have you had an opportunity to talk with returning troops? I encourage you to do so. It might give you a different picture of what our military presence is accomplishing. I recently spoke with a Marine who returned in October from Husaybah on the Syrian border. This is where my son is now. There is no CNN or Fox news - the citizens get their news from Al Jazeerah. He and my son both say the same things. 90% of the folks who live there are accepting of the Marine's presence and know that the only way to rid their country of those who wish to keep them in oppression is to fight them. The other 10% are the ones bent on oppressing the majority and the Marines are taking care of them. The Marine I spoke with said that the single worst moment for his squad was when a small girl wandered into the middle of a fire fight. Two Marines put their own safety directly on the line when they raced into the line of fire to bring her to safety. You do not hear about incidents like that but they are far more common than the accidental deaths of civilians.
In Fallujah, our Marines were approached by local citizens who begged them to take out the insurgents that were making their lives hell. When they went into homes, there were notes from the people who lived there, offering the food in their refrigerators, telling the Marines to sleep in their beds, supporting our troops as they fought to remove the terror. They knew that their homes might be destroyed in the process of cleaning the city of terror. Many of them were willing to make this sacrifice. You didn't read about this but I've heard a number of independent accounts from our troops. And, for those who suffered property damage, our troops are now helping them to rebuild.
In many of your comments, you've criticized our troops for eating when locals are starving. Do you have empirical evidence to support this? I haven't been able to find it. In each region, military civil affairs staff work directly with local populations to make sure that they have sufficient food, clean water, access to education, vocational training, etc. They are helping local citizens reclaim their country. Iraqis are proud people and they do not want handouts - they want to take care of themselves. They are accomplishing this with the help and protection of our military. When my son returned from Najaf last year, he told me that if the people who opposed this war could see the difference on the faces of the Iraqi people before and after, they would have a different opinion. People who stayed in their houses for fear of arrest or imprisonment by Saddam's thugs were free to enjoy the simple things that we take for granted in this country. Walking down a street. Reading a newspaper. Watching television. Accessing the world through the internet (many cities have internet cafes now - something that was forbidden under Saddam's rule).
In Najaf last year, our Marines rebuilt schools that had been subverted by the Fedayeen into munitions warehouses. They brought freedom to a region that had been brutally oppressed. And when they left in October 2004, citizens lined the streets and wept. They did not want the Marines to leave. I have so many examples of how our troops have embodied Kant's second formulation of treating the humanity of Iraqis as an end state. They are leaving this region a better place. A freer place.
And, your view of the military leaves me wondering where you gained your perspective. I don't know much about the Army but the Marine Corps does not train "golems". The men and women of the Corps are trained to work cohesively as a team but they are also encouraged to use their intelligence and problem-solving skills. They are not treated as lumps of clay to be molded into mindless robots. And they not only have consciences but soldiers and Marines who do not have this critical component are weeded out. Compassion has a place on the battlefield. And it is one of the reasons that we are on this particular battlefield.
I think you have some interesting ideas and I wish you well with your endeavors. You are welcome to stay and add your ideas. It's the trolls that come in and spew hatred that I will not tolerate. You don't fall into that category.
Deb Conrad
Proud Marine Mom
Posted by: Deb at January 4, 2005 08:02 AM


